tabs ↹ over ␣ ␣ ␣ spaces

by Jiří {x2} Činčura

True and False functions as “oneliners”

29 Jun 2020 1 mins C#

I was reading Stephen Cleary’s A New Pattern for Exception Logging blogpost and the True and False methods caught my eye and I wanted to write them as “oneliners”.

By “oneliner” I mean method that’s using expression body. If you’re looking for answer to “Why?", I don’t have it. So, let’s consider it a quick exercise in C#.

The expression body as the name implies, has to be expression and not bunch of statements in a block. I need to call an Action and return bool. Which is actually Func<bool>. Having that it’s easy to do so.

public static bool False(Action action) => new Func<bool>(() => { action(); return false; })();

You might not like the new being there, luckily casting works just fine.

public static bool False(Action action) => ((Func<bool>)(() => { action(); return false; }))();

Both versions result in same IL, so at the end of the day, it’s only about your personal preference.

And finally, as a little bit of fiddling it can be made bit more obfuscated. Or succinct?

using a = System.Action;
using b = System.Func<bool>;
class C
	const bool f = false;
	public static bool False(a a) => ((b)(() => { a(); return f; }))();

I’ll leave this exercise here, because I feel it could end up with very ugly code.

Profile Picture Jiří Činčura is .NET, C# and Firebird expert. He's focused on data and business layers, language constructs, parallelism, databases and performance. He's Microsoft Most Valuable Professional and frequent speaker. You can read his articles, guides and tips and tricks at